Strategies to get Social Proof & Product Reviews during and after BFCM

Strategies to get Social Proof & Product Reviews during and after BFCM

Must-have automations to get more product reviews before, during and after the BFCM/ holiday season sale.

During the BFCM and holiday season sale, customers find it even harder to trust eCommerce stores – despite the heavy discounts and deals available on their favorite products.

The reason? Increasing number of online frauds.

Cyber Peace Foundation has identified over 100K malicious domains that hosted fraudulent eCommerce stores. From social media to online marketplaces and other selling sites, the study found that 4 out of 10 consumers have experienced purchase frauds in one way or another.

So no matter how many marketing and advertising campaigns you’re running to promote ongoing deals during BFCM, you can’t do social proof.

Social proof – Product reviews.

That’s why, in this blog and as part of our Ultimate BFCM 2025 Guide & Tips for Shopify Store, we’re going to share some tactics to help you get more product reviews – before, during, and after the holiday rush.

What Is Social Proof and Why Does It Matter for Ecommerce?

Social proof is a psychology-based marketing concept that says a large portion of customers’ buying decisions are based on the choices and experiences of their fellow consumers. For eCommerce stores, this translates to images, reviews, and content that shows the reliability and quality of different products and experiences.

This concept of social proof is as old as marketing itself. But with the digital revolution and introduction of eCommerce, its accessibility and effectiveness have improved.

Here are five statistics that show how social proof (product reviews) can help boost your eCommerce store’s sales:

  • 92% of eCommerce customers find it easy to trust non-paid recommendations compared to marketing and advertising campaigns.
  • If there’s a verified purchase badge, more than 70% of the customers will trust the review even when they don’t know them.
  • Almost 90% of the customers trust user-generated reviews as much as a personal recommendation.
  • 97% of Shopify customers say online reviews impact their buying decision.
  • Positive reviews make 68% of customers more likely to buy a product from an eCommerce store.

During BFCM and the holiday season, the influence of reviews goes higher because customers rely on them to avoid being cheated. Having social proof integrated during this sale period can reduce the bounce rate and improve the conversion rate for your eCommerce store.

But you can’t just put reviews on your site during the BFCM and expect it to deliver satisfactory results.

For it to improve your sales during that time, you need to start working on it right from this very moment.

How to Collect Social Proof/ Product Reviews Before BFCM

Having worked with Shopify stores across the globe, we know that giving customers heavy discounts is not the most efficient way to make your BFCM sales successful. One of the evergreen strategies is integrating social proof into your store.

A lot of customers are going to reach your store before BFCM or the holiday season to pre-plan their purchases. You must have reviews on your site before the season to cater to these customers. Here’s how you can collect social proof before BFCM:

1. Reach Out to Top Customers

2. Set Up Automated Sequence for All Purchases Leading To BFCM

One of the best times to ask for a review from customers is when the product is delivered to them. At this time, they are happy that they have received the new product and are very excited about it. You can set up an email or web push automation to ask for their reviews, product image, etc.

Moreover, you can set up this automation from this very moment to collect as many reviews as possible. These reviews will not only be beneficial for your BFCM sale but will also convert more customers in general.

Let’s look at some copies you can test:

3. Offer Credits/ Discounts in Lieu of the Reviews

4. Request Review With Pop-ups for Returning Visitors

Just like your top customers, the customers who are returning to your store can easily be convinced to leave a review. Like we said earlier — they only come back when they are satisfied with the previous purchase.

You can use pop-ups to encourage these users to leave a review about their past shopping experiences. If they are not in a hurry, more often than not, they’ll definitely leave a review.
You can target returning visitors with these copies:

How to Collect Social Proof/ Product Reviews During BFCM

During the BFCM and holiday seasons, customers jump from one store to another to find the best deals. They are busy.

This makes it harder for you to get a review from them during this time. Here are some tactics to get reviews from them even during their busy shopping schedule:

1. Automated Email and Web Push

2. Take Review on Purchase Completion

3. Unlock More Discounts for Reviews

4. Offer Store Credits

5. Give Freebies to Reviewers

6. Use Pop-Ups

Another great thing about getting a lot of reviews before and during the BFCM and holidays is that even when things start to dry up a little bit when the sale is gone, these reviews will help in conversion.

Looking for a platform that can send automated web pushes and emails to collect reviews? Check out AiTrillion!

How to Collect Social Proof/ Product Reviews After BFCM

The time after BFCM is slow. There are not a lot of sales because everyone has already spent a lot during the sale. But if you do nothing during this time, customers will just forget how good your sale was. You need to stay in the mind of those who purchased from you.

Here are some tactics to receive social proof and keep customers engaged after the holiday season.

1. Send Out a Feedback Request

2. Automated Emails and Web Push

Best Practices to Follow for Getting More Reviews

Ask the Right Questions

Make It Simple to Submit

Showcase the Reviews You Get

Encourage Customers to Submit Photos With Reviews

SEO-Optimized Reviews Bring More Sales

Automatic Reminders

Harness the Power of Social Proof to Boost Sales

Ayush

Ayush Verma

Like what we do?  Come work with us

Do you want more revenue from

 your Shopify store?

We at AiTrillion cater to every aspect of the customer journey; from engagement, and conversion to retention at 55% less cost.

Error: Contact form not found.

Ready to Simplify and Scale Your Shopify Marketing?

Switch to AiTrillion and unify your customer experience with smarter, automated tools.

Easy integration with Shopify | Replace 11+ apps and save costs | Built for retention and revenue growth

Book A Demo
Book a Demo